What we do
IPAM is the independent accountability mechanism of the EBRD. IPAM reviews environmental, social and transparency-related issues raised by Project-affected people and civil society organisations about EBRD financed projects, which are believed to have caused harm. Our ultimate goal is to ensure that the Projects financed by the EBRD are implemented in line with the Bank's commitments to environmental and social sustainability.
The purpose of the mechanism is to:
Facilitate the resolution of disputes between Project-affected People, the Bank, and EBRD Clients
Determine whether the Bank has complied with its Environmental and Social Policy and Access to Information Policy
Share institutional learnings with Bank staff, where common challenges are identified, promoting continuous learning at EBRD
Engage with stakeholders across countries of operation, to ensure IPAM’s purpose, functions and activities are known and understood by all stakeholders.
IPAM’s work is guided by principles of independence and impartiality; transparency; predictability; equitability and accessibility.
Our governance and structure
IPAM operates independently of Bank management, reporting directly and only to the EBRD Board of Directors.
Victoria Marquez-Mees, a Mexican national, is the EBRD's first Chief Accountability Officer (CAO). She is Managing Director of IPAM responsible for the setting up and operation of the office. Prior to joining the EBRD, Ms. Márquez-Mees led the Inter-American Development Bank’s independent accountability mechanism for over 10 years and chaired the Independent Accountability Mechanisms Network of international financial institutions from 2017-19. With more than 30 years professional experience in international development, she has held a range of positions in public and private institutions, focused on strategic planning, policy design and the implementation of social and philanthropic projects. She is a member of the Boards of the World Benchmarking Alliance and the International Association for Impact Assessment (IAIA). She is fluent in English, Spanish and Portuguese.
Sushma Kotagiri, an Indian national, leads the Effectiveness, Outreach and Advisory function and acts as deputy to the CAO. Ms Kotagiri is a social specialist with extensive operational project experience across 20 countries. Prior to IPAM, she was a Principal Facilitation Specialist at the ADB's Office of the Special Project Facilitator, where she applied her social development and safeguards background to the dispute resolution processes managed under the accountability mechanism. Also at ADB, she has led social risk management, stakeholder engagement and quality assurance components of IFI investments in the infrastructure sector. Sushma worked with Oxfam GB and the private sector, mainstreaming social and gender dimensions into projects within the natural resources sector. She is fluent in English, Hindi, Telugu and has a basic knowledge of French.
Sarah Hanes, a Canadian national, leads the Compliance Review function. She joined the EBRD in 2017 to spearhead the redesign of the Mechanism as part of the 2019 EBRD Good Governance Policy Review and was appointed PCM Officer in June 2019. Sarah is an ESG specialist with over 13 years experience in environmental and social impact assessment, stakeholder engagement and poilcy reform from her work with environmental consulsatnies and the Government of Canada, in both project development and accountability roles. Her function is currently being covered by the CAO as she is on special leave until March 2022. She is fluent in English, French and has a basic knowledge of Portuguese.
Olga Vasiliev, a Moldavian and Romanian national, leads on the Problem Solving function of IPAM. Before that, she worked for five years with the Project Complaint Mechanism. Olga is a lawyer by training and accredited mediator with 16 years of working experience in the development sector. Prior to the EBRD, she worked with the UNDP, Council of Europe, IREX and French Red Cross. Ms. Vasiliev brings, to the Problem Solving function, a vast experience in the design, implementation and monitoring of complex development and humanitarian projects, as well as first hand practice in dispute resolution processes in a range of EBRD’s countries of operation. She is fluent in English, French, Russian, Romanian and has an intermediate level of Ukrainian.
Kinga Jaromin, a Polish national, holds the position of Associate within IPAM's Compliance Review team. Prior to joining EBRD, Ms. Jaromin worked as an Associate at Morgan Stanley conducting due diligence reviews on ESG, criminal and reputational issues across Bank’s diverse clients. She also worked with the EU Agency for Fundamental Rights in Vienna in the Consultation and Cooperation Unit and human rights focused civil society sector. She is fluent in English, Polish and has a working knowledge of Russian and Ukrainian.
Giorgio Napoli, an Italian national, holds the position of Analyst at IPAM. He is responsible for the request intake stage, managing our case database and providing support to the outreach programme. Mr. Napoli brings relevant experience across communication, finance and data analysis. Prior to EBRD, he worked as a communication strategist, supervision data analyst and personal financial advisor at the Fineco Bank, Domino Web Agency and the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA). He is fluent in English and Italian and has a working knowledge of French and Spanish.
Gina Llewelyn, a British national, is the Executive Assistant to the CAO. She also supports the IPAM team in diverse administrative, budgetary, logistical and procurement tasks. Mrs Llewelyn brings over 25 years of experience in events and administration from both public and private sector companies. She has worked at EBRD at various times in different departments over the last 20 years. In between working at EBRD, she has worked for The Commonwealth War Graves Commission, Credit Agricole Corporate and Investment Bank and Hill & Knowlton Strategies. She is fluent in English and has a basic knowledge of French and Italian.
Niall Watson, a New Zealand and British national, provides technical support to the Compliance Review team as a consultant. Mr. Watson brings over 30 years’ experience as an environmental lawyer working across New Zealand Ministry for the Environment, a private law firm in London and as General Counsel and Programmes Legal Adviser at WWF-UK. His expertise is focused on international and EU environmental law related to mining, oil exploration, climate change, deforestation, freshwater and marine protection, wildlife conservation, and corporate environmental and social governance and accountability.
Our partners - the Independent Accountability Mechanisms’ Network
All IFIs have externally focused, citizen-driven accountability mechanisms, referred to as Independent Accountability Mechanism (IAMs). Although their scope and mandates vary, they all receive submissions of concern from external stakeholders about the environmental and social performance of their institutions’ projects.
The IAMs Network brings together international practitioners in accountability, compliance, mediation and corporate governance. It provides a platform for cooperation and the exchange of expertise for accountability mechanisms worldwide.
IPAM is part of the IAMs Network. Participation in the Network allows for the exchange of best practices, the strengthening of relationships with civil society organisations and peer institutions, and collaboration on co-financed projects where corncerns are raised.
|INTERNATIONAL FINANCIAL INSTITUTION||ACCOUNTABILITY MECHANISM|
African Development Bank
|Asian Development Bank (ADB)||Accountability Mechanism (AM)|
|Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB)||Project-affected People’s Mechanism (PPM)|
|Black Sea Trade and Development||Internal Audit Department|
|Caribbean Development Bank||Project Complaints Mechanism|
European Investment Bank (EIB)
|Complaints Mechanism (CM)|
|European Union (EU)||European Ombudsman|
|French Development Agency (AFD)||Environmental and Social Complaints Mechanism|
German Development Bank (DEG)
Netherlands Development Finance Company (FMO)
|Green Climate Fund||Redress Mechanism (IRM)|
|Inter-American Development Bank||Independent Consultation and Investigation Mechanism|
|International Bank for Reconstruction and Development (IBRD) - World Bank Group||Inspection Panel (IPN)|
International Finance Corporation and Multilateral (IFC) and Investment Guarantee Agency (MIGA) - World Bank Group
|Compliance Advisor Ombudsman (CAO)|
|Japan Bank for International Cooperation (JBIC)||Office of the Examiner for Objection Procedures on Environmental Guidelines|
|Japan International Cooperation Agency (JICA)||Office of the Chief Compliance Officer|
|Nippon Export and Investment Insurance (NEXI)||Office of Accountability (OA)|
|Nordic Investment Bank (NIB)||Social and Environmental Compliance Review and Stakeholder Response Mechanism|
|United Nations Development Program (UNDP)||Social and Environmental Compliance Review and Stakeholder Response Mechanism|
|United States International Development Finance Corporation (DFC)||Office of Accountability|